Recruiting Basics

Retained Search

Retained search is an engagement model in which an employer pays a search firm in staged instalments to run an exclusive search, rather than paying only if a hire is made. The fee buys the work itself: market research, mapping, direct approach, assessment and structured reporting, delivered against an agreed timetable.

How does a retained search engagement work in practice?

In stages, with money attached to each. An initial instalment starts the work, a second is commonly tied to delivery of a shortlist or to a point in the calendar, and the balance falls due on placement or when the hire starts. Between those points the firm produces a written role specification, maps the relevant market to establish who is actually doing this work and where, approaches those people directly, assesses the ones worth pursuing, and presents a short list of names with written evidence behind each. Progress reporting runs on an agreed cadence whether or not there is good news, which is part of what the fee covers. Exclusivity is normal for the engagement period, so no other firm and often no internal channel works the role in parallel.

What does retained change compared with contingency?

The incentives, and everything that follows from them. A contingency firm is paid only when a placement happens, so it spreads effort across many roles, moves fast, and sends the strongest people it already knows. That produces speed and volume, costs the employer nothing if no hire results, and rarely yields a systematic view of the market. A retained firm is paid for conducting the search, so time goes into research: mapping a market properly, reaching people who are not looking and would ignore an advert, and reporting on who declined and why. The employer carries the risk if the search stalls, which is the real trade being made. Direct approach work happens under both models. What changes is who funds the research and how much of it actually gets done.

When does retained search fit, and when is contingency the better choice?

Retained fits small candidate universes and high consequence. Executive appointments, scarce specialist roles, confidential searches where an incumbent is still in post, positions where a wrong hire is expensive to unwind, and markets where the right people are not applying anywhere all justify paying for research. It also fits when you need evidence about the market itself and not only a hire. Contingency fits the opposite conditions: an active candidate pool, profiles that are genuinely interchangeable, several similar roles running at once, and a market where speed matters more than coverage. Plenty of employers run both, using contingency and their own direct sourcing for volume roles while reserving retained engagements for a handful of appointments a year. Building internal pipelines with [candidate sourcing software](/candidate-sourcing-software) reduces how often either becomes necessary.

What does an employer have to provide under either model?

Access, speed and honesty about the role. A proper briefing that goes well beyond the job description, a named decision maker who can act without convening a committee, interview slots held in advance, a pay range you will genuinely honour, and feedback within days rather than weeks. Under a retained engagement this matters more than usual, because the firm is approaching people who were not looking and is representing you while it does so. Slow feedback undoes weeks of persuasion, and a candidate who was talked into a conversation and then left waiting rarely comes back. Decide the off-limits terms up front, agree how the search is described if it is confidential, and treat the engagement as part of your own [talent acquisition](/talent-acquisition) process rather than something happening elsewhere.

See how Pitch N Hire handles retained search on your roles

Related questions

Choosing your recruiting stack

Next step

FAQ

Retained Search — FAQs

Is retained search the same as executive search? +
They overlap heavily and the terms get used interchangeably, but they describe different things. Retained describes how the firm is engaged and paid. Executive search describes the seniority of the role. Most executive appointments run on a retained basis, and retained engagements are also used well below executive level whenever the relevant market is small enough to justify the research.
Can a role be run retained and contingency at the same time? +
It defeats the point. Exclusivity is what makes the research investment rational for the firm, so a retained consultant working alongside contingency competitors will sensibly cut the mapping work and revert to sending known names quickly. If you want several firms competing, use contingency terms and accept what that model produces. Pick one approach per role instead of blending them.
What should a retained search report contain? +
The market map with the organizations and role types covered, how many people were approached, how many engaged, the reasons given by those who declined, and the assessed shortlist with evidence against the agreed criteria. Anything learned that should change the brief belongs there too. Feedback about pay expectations or an unrealistic requirement is often the most valuable output, however unwelcome.
What happens if a retained search does not produce a hire? +
That depends entirely on the engagement letter, so read it before signing. Common arrangements include a defined extension at no further fee, a replacement search within a set period, or staged instalments that simply stop. Some agreements offer nothing beyond work performed. Agree the position in advance, along with what happens if the role is canceled or the specification changes materially mid-search.
Built for recruiters & hiring teams

See Retained Search in action

Pitch N Hire unifies sourcing, screening and hiring decisions on one AI-native platform. Book a quick demo on your real roles.

Prefer to talk? Book a demo · View pricing

Free 1-user plan · No credit card · Talk to a real hiring expert

One Hiring Infrastructure.
Zero Tool Chaos.

Demos are consultative. We respect privacy and enterprise
governance. No lock-ins.

Start free Book demo