Recruitment agency fees depend on the model. Permanent-placement agencies, whether contingency or retained, typically charge a percentage of the hire's first-year salary. Temporary and contract staffing agencies charge an hourly markup over the worker's pay rate. Exact percentages and markups vary by role seniority, skill scarcity, and negotiation, so confirm the fee structure before you engage.
For permanent roles, agencies almost always price as a percentage of the placed candidate's first-year base salary rather than a flat fee, so a more senior, higher-paid hire costs more to fill. Contingency agencies collect this percentage only when their candidate is actually hired, which means they carry the risk of an unsuccessful search. Retained firms charge the same kind of salary-based fee but split it into installments paid across the engagement regardless of outcome. The exact percentage is negotiable and moves with the difficulty and seniority of the role, so treat any single figure you hear as a starting point, not a fixed rate.
The difference is when and whether you pay, not just how much. Contingency is no-placement-no-fee: you owe nothing unless the agency's candidate is hired, which suits most everyday permanent roles and lets you run several agencies at once. Retained search asks for payment in stages — often an upfront portion, a milestone payment, and a completion payment — in exchange for an exclusive, dedicated, and typically more thorough search reserved for senior or hard-to-fill positions. Retained costs more in commitment and is paid win or lose, but buys deeper attention; contingency shifts the risk to the agency but may get less focused effort.
Temporary and contract staffing uses a completely different mechanism. Instead of a one-time placement fee, the agency bills an hourly rate for each hour the worker is on assignment, and that rate includes a markup over what the worker is actually paid. The markup covers the worker's wages, employer payroll taxes, any benefits, insurance, administration, and the agency's margin. Because the agency often remains the legal employer of a temp, you are paying for it to carry that employment burden as well as for sourcing. The size of the markup varies with skill level, assignment length, and how much of the employment risk the agency absorbs.
Several things move the price. Seniority and salary raise permanent fees directly because they are a percentage of pay. Scarcity matters — a role requiring a rare skill in a tight market commands a higher percentage than a common one an agency can fill from its existing pool. Exclusivity, volume, and an ongoing relationship give you leverage to negotiate lower rates, since agencies value a reliable client. Urgency and confidentiality can push fees up. And the service level plays in: a light contingency search costs less commitment than a deep retained engagement or a fully outsourced hiring process.
Before signing, get the commercials in writing so there are no surprises. Clarify the fee percentage or markup and exactly what triggers it, when payment is due, and whether the fee is based on base salary alone or total compensation. Crucially, agree a rebate or guarantee period — many permanent agreements refund part or all of the fee if the hire leaves within a defined early window — so you are protected if a placement does not stick. Also settle exclusivity, how candidate ownership is handled if two agencies submit the same person, and any replacement terms. These clauses matter as much as the headline rate.
You do not have to accept the first rate quoted. Negotiate the percentage, especially if you can offer exclusivity, multiple roles, or a longer relationship. Consolidate to a few trusted agencies rather than paying many for overlapping work. Reserve agencies for the roles that truly need them — the senior, niche, or urgent ones — and handle steady, high-volume, or easily sourced hiring internally. Building an in-house recruiting capability supported by an applicant tracking system like Pitch N Hire lets you fill routine roles without a placement fee each time, so agency budget is spent only where its network genuinely adds value.
It is a straight cost-benefit question. An agency fee can be substantial, but for a role that would otherwise stay open for months, sit outside your network, or require confidentiality, the speed and reach often justify the spend — an unfilled senior role has its own large hidden cost. For predictable, ongoing hiring, though, paying a placement fee on every hire quickly outweighs the cost of a recruiter and software. The economical pattern for most growing companies is internal hiring for the steady flow of roles, with agencies engaged selectively for the searches where their fee buys something you genuinely cannot do yourself.
Get a personalized walkthrough of Pitch N Hire on your own roles and workflow. No slides, no obligation.
Prefer to talk? Book a demo · View pricing
Free 1-user plan · No credit card · Talk to a real hiring expert
See how Pitch N Hire automates sourcing, screening and AI interviews on your real roles. Start with your work email — no credit card.
★ Free 1-user plan · No spam · Talk to a real hiring expert
